In a recent case of Suterwalla and another v HMRC, taxpayers won an appeal against HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) in respect of the payment of Stamp Duty Land Tax on mixed-use property. HMRC tried to claim that the property was wholly residential, meaning that a substantially higher level of tax would have been payable.
The background
The taxpayers, Mr and Mrs Suterwalla, had purchased a property together with a garden, tennis court, and paddock. They held that the paddock was not part of the garden or grounds of their home and that it was used as separate commercial premises.
They leased the paddock from the date of completion of the purchase for £1,000 per annum for horses to be grazed there.
Stamp Duty was paid on a mixed-use basis.
HMRC declared that the property was wholly residential and required the Stamp Duty payment to be increased by £161,250, from £169,500 to £330,750 to reflect this.
An initial statutory review of the decision found in favour of HMRC, upholding their decision. The taxpayers appealed to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber).
The tribunal decision
It was for the applicants, Mr and Mrs Suterwalla, to show that they had been overcharged tax on the balance of probabilities.
HMRC’s Stamp Duty Land Tax manual says that in deciding whether a property is in residential or mixed-use, historic and future use should be considered as well as its layout and how close the area in question is to the dwelling.
The tribunal considered the meaning of ‘residential property’ and what area constituted ‘grounds of a dwelling’, taking into account the following:
- The paddock has a separate purpose from the house and does not support the house, garden, or tennis court.
- The paddock is not an integral part of the property and is not visible from the property.
- There is only a small gate between the paddock and the garden, and the whole property is owned as one.
- The individual leasing the paddock does not access the paddock through the garden, although she has the right to.
The tribunal decided that the lease of the paddock meant that it did not form part of the grounds of the dwelling.
It ruled that HMRC was not entitled to the additional Stamp Duty on the grounds that:
- The paddock cannot be seen from the property or gardens.
- There is only a single small point of access to the paddock from the garden.
- The individual leasing the paddock accesses it without entering the garden.
- The lease is a commercial one.
- The title to the house, garden, and tennis court is separate to the title to the paddock.
- The taxpayers stated that they would not have purchased the paddock had they had this option.
This ruling differs from another recent case, Brandbros Ltd v HMRC [2021]. In that case, the garage of a residential property was leased under a commercial lease on the day of completion. The First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) did not accept that this made the premises mixed-use and the taxpayer was required to pay residential Stamp Duty Land Tax on the whole value of the premises.
It is open to HMRC to appeal the decision.
Contact our residential property solicitors in Westminster, London
At William Sturges, we deal with residential sales and purchases. These transactions can often include mixed-use land.
David Cross is a partner in the Residential Property team. He advises on a range of property matters, including sales and purchases of high value properties for individual, family office and developer clients.
If you would like to speak to David, contact him by ringing 020 7873 1000, email him at law@williamsturges.co.uk or fill in our contact form below.