With the effects of the pandemic lingering, the courts have increasingly been asked to deal with commercial lease renewals as landlords and tenants try to negotiate new annual rents and other lease terms in an uncertain climate.
The following cases have highlighted the issues below:
HPUT Trustee No.1 Ltd v Boots UK Ltd [2021]
W (No. 3) GP (Nominee A) v JD Sports Fashion [2021]
S Frances Ltd v The Cavendish Hotel (London) Ltd [2021]
WH Smith Retail Holdings Limited v Commerz Real Investmentgesellshaft MBH [2021]
Poundland Ltd v Toplain Ltd [2021]
Interim rent should not be based on the new rent but should be higher
Retail rents have fallen by around 20-30% because of the pandemic, with some major stores ceasing trading and others able to achieve substantially lower rents on renewal.
The courts have found in several cases that interim rent should be higher than the new rent because rents during the interim period were higher on the whole. The level of interim rent is particularly important at present because of the length of time a case can take to be decided. In JD Sports and S Frances, interim rents covered around four to five years.
Turnover rents and fixed increases
It was noted in JD Sports that it is very hard to justify a turnover rent on renewal, even where the old lease was based on turnover. In the current climate, a turnover rent will only be appropriate where the rent that would be payable is consistent with current market rents or in special cases such as rents for car parks.
Fixed rent increases are also unlikely to be imposed, with the courts finding that there is no market for fixed increases.
Comparable leases
The courts have tended to use a single comparable when looking at relevant nearby premises. The nearest and most relevant comparable is used and adjustments are made for differences in size, frontage and location.
Rent suspension clauses
Rent suspension clauses are being requested on the renewal of commercial leases in case further lockdowns are ordered. The judge in WH Smith allowed that the rent could be reduced by half, while in Poundland the court did not permit a rent suspension clause to be added, saying that there would need to be a good reason for a change.
Break clauses
Break clauses are relatively easy to justify in the current market, with the court finding in HPUT that the landlord would have to justify why a break clause should not be allowed where the old lease included an annual right to break. A break clause after three years was found to be reasonable as this would give the landlord a level of security and also allow the market to improve so that the premises would be easier to re-let, should the tenant decide to exercise the clause when the time comes.
The length of the new lease
New leases are likely to be for five years unless the parties agree on a different term. In HPUT the court found that the ten-year lease requested by the landlord would not give the tenant sufficient flexibility in an uncertain market.
Contact our commercial rent dispute solicitors in Westminster, London
At William Sturges, we have extensive experience in negotiating commercial lease renewals and we are often able to resolve difficulties by negotiation, avoiding the need for protracted legal action.
James Hannon is head of the Litigation and Dispute Resolution Department and is recognised as an expert in commercial dispute resolution and arbitration.
If you would like to speak to James, contact him by ringing 020 7873 1000, email him at law@williamsturges.co.uk or fill in our contact form below.