Insights

remain anonymous in ransomware attack

High Court allows victim to remain anonymous in ransomware attack

The High Court has permitted a business to remain anonymous when bringing a legal case following a ransomware attack.

In recent years, victims of cybercrime have been required to reveal their identity in open court when they have sought injunctions to try to prevent the publication of illegally procured information. This has made the position of those at the mercy of ransomware demands even more difficult, as they face public identification as well as blackmail.

However, in a recent case, the claimant was allowed to remain unnamed.

XXX v Persons Unknown [2022] EWHC 2776 (KB)

The claimant in the case is a multi-discipline business that provide technology services including the hosting of databases. Some of the databases contained data that was subject to the Official Secrets Act 1989 and that related to national security.

In March 2022, the business received a ransom note advising it that cyber attackers had downloaded the claimant’s databases, FTP server and file server to its own servers. It also stated that the files had been encrypted so that the business would be unable to access them. A ransom of US$6.8 million was demanded in return for decryption of the files and non-disclosure of the databases. Evidence was provided that the files were indeed held by the attackers.

The majority of the information was either security sensitive or commercially sensitive. A substantial amount was highly classified and protected by the Official Secrets Act.

When an ultimatum was received on 29 March stating that the information would be posted online, the claimant applied to the court for a without notice interim injunction. This was intended to stop the attackers from publishing or otherwise using the stolen data. The court granted the order, which was served on the attackers using their email address. At the hearing, the claimant was also granted anonymity.

The following month, the claimant asked the court for a permanent injunction and damages for breach of confidence. The court continued the interim injunction and anonymity and granted the claimant’s request for a private hearing.

The defendant did not respond to the claim, although it had been made aware of it, and the court granted summary judgment in favour of the claimant and a permanent injunction with the option to return to court in respect of damages, should the identity of the attacker ever be discovered.

Granting anonymity

In considering whether to grant anonymity to the claimant, the judge considered whether there was anything that justified a departure from the principles of open justice.

In this case, he found that the nature of the work undertaken by the claimant meant that if its identity was revealed, third parties with malign intent such as hostile nation states, organised criminal groups and terrorist organisations could try to find the information online on the Dark Web or attempt to contact the attackers.
This meant there was a risk of a ‘very great deal of harm’ being done to the claimant just by disclosing their identity.

The final hearing was heard in public as the judge held that anonymity was enough to protect the claimant and derogation from open justice should go no further than necessary.

He noted that for anonymity to be granted in respect of a claim following a cyber attack a business would need to be at risk of more then just negative commercial and reputational consequences. This would not automatically be sufficient to protect the claimant’s identity.

The court would need to consider in future cases whether it was necessary to grant anonymity to prevent the court itself from becoming an instrument of harm by identifying the source of information that may then become available to purchase.

Contact our technology solicitors in Westminster, London

Martin Donoghue is a partner in the Company and Commercial department with particular expertise in the technology sector, in particular with fintech and cryptocurrency.

If you would like to speak to Martin or one of his team, call 020 7873 1000, email law@williamsturges.co.uk or fill in our contact form below.

Share