Insights

Landlords Proceeds of Crime

Landlord ordered to pay in excess of £175,000 on account of tenant’s unlawful activity

A recent case between Manchester City Council and T&M Investments Limited has highlighted the risk for commercial landlords of allowing tenants to carry out unlawful activities at their premises.

Background

The landlord, T&M Property (T&M) held a 999-year lease of a premises on Manchester’s Curry Mile and subleased the property to a restaurant called Dubai Café. The tenant started operating an illegal shisha café on the premises in breach of planning laws.

In 2018, Manchester City Council discovered the unlawful use of a shisha café as well as unauthorised alterations to provide seating at the front for shisha smoking. It served an enforcement notice on the landlord, requiring the café to cease operating as a shisha establishment. The notice also required the landlord to reinstate the frontage so that it was no longer in breach of planning consent.

The council spent more than four years unsuccessfully attempting to enforce the terms of the notice, including two visits to confiscate shisha pipes and tobacco, but the restaurant continued to operate the shisha smoking area.

The landlord did not forfeit the lease, allowing the unlawful conduct to continue until a prosecution against the landlord by Manchester City Council was started.

Guilty plea

T&M pleaded guilty to breaches of the planning rules and was fined £18,750 and ordered to pay the council’s costs of £5,700.

Proceeds of crime application

The council also made an application under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. This allows courts to order that a party who has benefited financially from crime must hand over the money or other assets they have received. Penalties for failing to comply with a Proceeds of Crime order include imprisonment.

The court ordered T&M to pay £175,074 to Manchester Council. This represents rental income for the period from the date on which the enforcement notice was issued up until the point when T&M ended the lease. T&M was also ordered to pay the council’s costs of the application.

Manchester City Council’s Gavin White, executive member for housing and development, said: “Local residents have had to put up with this criminal activity for too long and this judgment – along with the confiscation of their illegally obtained profit – sends a clear message to other businesses flagrantly breaking the law that we are looking for you and we will prosecute. This case also shows that landlords can’t hide behind their tenants – they will be held responsible for criminality on their property.”

Insights

The outcome of the case highlights the risks to a landlord of ignoring unlawful activity at its premises. The landlord does not have to be guilty of any criminal activity to face a Proceeds of Crime Act claim. It is enough that a landlord knows or suspects wrongdoing. Where the money generated by unlawful activity may be going towards paying the rent, there is a clear risk that the rent could later be confiscated.

Landlords are advised to consider how they manage premises. It may be necessary to carry out regular inspections to make sure laws are not being broken. Where the tenant is breaching the rules, it is crucial to act immediately. If the tenant continues to act unlawfully, the lease should be forfeited.

Contact our commercial property solicitors in Westminster, London

At William Sturges, we provide a full service to commercial landlords, including advice on enforcing lease conditions and lease forfeiture.

James Hannon is head of Litigation and Dispute Resolution and is recognised as an expert in commercial dispute resolution and arbitration.

If you would like to speak to James, contact him by ringing 020 7873 1000

Share