To Return or Not to Return?
Just because the Government’s order to work from home is a thing of the past, does not mean being an employer is going to get any easier.
The legal issues surrounding employees returning to the office may prove just as challenging as those that resulted from the original work from home instruction.
Some employees may wish to continue working from home, at least for some of the time, because they feel that a lack of office distractions, or no time wasted on a commute, makes them more productive with the additional benefit of a better work/life balance.
In contrast, some employees may wish to return to the office because they feel they have a lack of support at home, or they have mental health issues that are exacerbated by being isolated. Without a clear policy on homeworking, some employees may feel that they are having to do more than “their fair share” if they are in the office and others are not.
As an employer you may have seen an upturn in productivity with people being at home. With technology you may feel you can monitor employees output at home and encourage those who are falling behind their peers. or perhaps you no longer have the physical space for all employees to return at the same time if you have moved to smaller offices.
Equally you may have found working at home to be inefficient or unfair on some staff, so you want a return to the office as soon as possible.
So, what are some possible issues if you want staff to return to the office, but some do not want to, or with staff who want to return but you do not want them to?
First, looking at those who want to remain away, and then at those who wish to return, some of the issues are as follows:
I don’t want to come back.
There is an employee’s right to request flexible working, which has been contained in law since 2014.
Essentially, if an employee meets certain requirements, they can request a change to certain terms of their employment. If they do so, an employer must follow a strict process and can only refuse a request on certain specified grounds. If an employer is to fall foul of this law it can only do so by failing to follow the proper process – the reasonableness of its decision is not up for challenge.
Although the flexible working regulations are currently under review, it is unlikely there will be substantial changes.
Next, although there is no general contractual duty for an employer to act reasonably, the Courts have recognised for many years that an employer must not act in a way that is likely to break the trust and confidence an employee is entitled to have in their employer.
It may be possible that an employer could break this duty if it does not let an employee work at home, at least for some of their working week, especially if some are allowed to work from home and some are not.
Finally, there are potential discrimination pitfalls, not just if an employee is denied home working, but also if they are granted some degree of home working.
For instance, if an employee is denied home working, can they argue this is less favourable treatment because of a certain characteristic they have that the law protects? Can a disabled employee argue that forcing them back to the office discriminates against them as they are disabled and it is easier for them to work from home than in the office?
Equally there are potential discrimination issues if an employee is allowed home working. For example, a woman who is paid less because she works from home may argue that this breaks Equal Pay legislation?
I don’t want to work at home.
There are also potential issues if an employee wishes to return to the workplace, but their employee does not or cannot agree to this.
For example, can you insist that an employee stays away if their contract clearly says they have a fixed place of work, and that is the employer’s office, or can you argue that an employee is required to be flexible over where they work or in adopting new working methods?
And, if an employer insists that an employee cannot return, is there a redundancy situation?
Furthermore, an employee who is denied a return to work may argue that the employer has broken the trust and confidence rule mentioned above.
And finally, an employee who suffers from mental health issues may argue this is disability discrimination as the support on offer in the office far exceeds that which can be given at home.
So, what to do?
That’s a difficult question and one that is too nuanced for a short article!
As an employer, you will probably need to consider what is best for your business, and then adopt a policy to reflect this, probably after consultation with your employees. With any change in employee policy, it is always advisable to seek legal advice specific to your particular circumstances before they are actioned, so that all issues are considered, and the correct procedures put in place. And you should also be aware that it is unlikely you will be able to please everybody.
Martin Donoghue is a highly experienced solicitor with expertise in commercial
and employment law. Martin can provide organisations with specialist advice on a wide range of employment matters including advising on board level employment agreements, tax advantageous employee share schemes, conflict resolution, restructuring, redundancy, and advice on the employment aspects of mergers and acquisitions. You can contact Martin here.