As with the case of Gowing v Ward [2024] EWCH 347 (CH), there are an increasing number of probate matters being disputed in and out of the Court room.
In this particular case, Mr Ward (the testator) changed his Will during the later years of his life, at a time when he was very unwell. The changes made by the testator, resulted in his five of his granddaughters receiving a reduced inheritance. Upon learning of these changes, the said granddaughters challenged the validity of the testator’s Will on the grounds of lack of capacity, want of knowledge and approval and / or undue influence.
The Judge found that Mr Ward had capacity when making his Will and rejected the granddaughters’ claims of undue influence and fraud.
While this case concerned the testator making changes to his Will, a Will can be contested even if a testator has only ever had one Will. Accordingly, it is important to understand the reasons why a Will can be contested. This is not to deter you from preparing your first Will or changing your Will, but rather to arm you with the necessary knowledge when you decide to do so.
The starting point when executing a Will is section 9 of the Wills Act 1837, which states that a Will must be:
- in writing;
- signed by the testator (or someone else in the testator’s presence and at his or her direction);
- the testator must intend when signing the will for it to be valid; and
- the testator’s signature must be acknowledged in the presence of at least two witnesses.
If your Will has been properly executed, it will be presumed the Will is valid. There are however grounds for contesting a Will even where the Will satisfies the above requirements, and it is important to bear these in mind when preparing or changing your current Will. The grounds are as follows:-
Lack of mental capacity
The burden of proof is on those alleging the testator did not have mental capacity when making or changing their Will. For a testator to have capacity, they must:
- Understand the nature of making a Will and its effect;
- Understand the extent of his or her property;
- Be able to comprehend and appreciate the claims to which he or she ought to give effect; and
- Have no illness that prevents the testator from thinking rationally.
Medical records and the opinion of a medical expert are particularly important in determining whether the testator has mental capacity.
Lack of understanding and approval of the contents of the Will
If the Court is suspicious of the testator lacking understanding and/or approval of the Will, this may cast doubt over the validity of the Will. Where this is the case, it is for those seeking to prove the validity of the Will to evidence that the deceased fully understood how the Will operated and approved the contents of the Will.
Examples of where suspicions might be raised are where:
- The testator was visually impaired or hard of hearing;
- The testator had low levels of literacy and the Will was not adjusted by the solicitor preparing the Will to account for this;
- The testator was frail, unwell or otherwise vulnerable and the Will is complex;
- A beneficiary in the Will played a big part in arranging the Will.
Undue influence
There is no presumption of undue influence. Accordingly, it is for those alleging there is undue influence to present the Court with sufficient evidence that the testator acted against their own free Will due to the influence or coercion of a third party.
The Court understands that, sometimes, vulnerable individuals are pressurised or coerced into making a Will they did not wish to make. However, as the nature of this allegation is so serious, and any pressure or coercion is likely to have taken place behind closed doors and away from other people, it is normally difficult to obtain sufficient evidence to satisfy the Court that there has been undue influence.
Forgery and fraud
If it can be proved that the Will has been forged, it will be deemed invalid. These claims are however rare.
Examples of this heading are where the handwriting and / or signature on the Will is different from the person who was supposed to make the Will, or where an individual has impersonated the testator, or where a beneficiary or non-beneficiary destroy versions of the Will for their gain.
Conclusion
As stated previously, it is important to bear the above in mind when changing your Will or preparing a Will for the first time.
Contact our private client department in Westminster, London
Danielle Ponds has extensive experience in drafting bespoke Wills and can work with you to ensure that you pass on your estate in the way that you want, avoiding difficulties for your loved ones when the time comes. If you would like to speak to Danielle, contact her by ringing 020 7873 1000 or email her at law@williamsturges.co.uk.