Insights

Intention to redevelop test

High Court provides guidance on ‘intention to redevelop’ test

The High Court has looked at when a landlord can legitimately oppose an application for a new tenancy on the grounds that it intends to demolish or reconstruct the premises.

Section 30(1)(f) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (the Act) allows a landlord to oppose an application to renew a tenancy where the landlord can demonstrate that:

“… on the termination of the current tenancy the landlord intends to demolish or reconstruct the premises comprised in the holding or a substantial part of those premises or to carry out substantial work of construction on the holding or part thereof and that he could not reasonably do so without obtaining possession of the holding.”

Where a landlord does not have grounds to oppose it, a tenant can apply to renew a tenancy if it has security of tenure.

Man Ltd v Back Inn Time Diner Ltd – the facts of the case

In the recent case of Man Ltd v Back Inn Time Diner Ltd, a landlord opposed a request to renew a lease, advising the tenant that it intended to develop the premises into a multi-storey, mixed-use development.

The tenant, who was running a successful American-style diner at the property, took the case to court claiming that the landlord had not satisfied the legal test in respect of intention to develop.

The court of first instance found in favour of the tenant, finding that the landlord lacked the objective intention to develop, demonstrated by:

  1. The lack of any real prospect of obtaining planning consent, which had initially been refused and was being appealed; and
  2. Lack of evidence that the landlord would be able to fund a development

The landlord appealed to the High Court.

What were the issues of the case?

The High Court was asked to consider the ‘real, as opposed to fanciful, prospect’ test in respect of the landlord’s intention.

There needed to be a ‘realistic prospect’ of implementing the intention, ie. developing, and it was not necessary to go as far as showing that the landlord ‘will be able’ to develop. The latter was too high a bar.

It is for the landlord to show that they have the intention to develop.

Ownership of other properties which could be used to raise funding might help, but there would need to be more evidence produced to the court than just ownership. The landlord would need to demonstrate a connection between owning other property and using it to secure funding.

High Court decision

Evidence of funding by way of bank statements was not disclosed by the landlord until the start of its evidence at the original trial. On consideration of relevant case law on late disclosure, the judge refused to admit the statements.

On appeal, Sir Anthony Mann found that the landlord’s failure was clearly serious, there was no good reason for the breach of pre-action protocols and the original judge’s decision could not be criticised.

There was also no error by the original judge in not referring in his judgment to evidence said to corroborate the landlord’s oral evidence that other properties were available to fund the development. The High Court found that while there was evidence of ownership of another property before the court, it had not been identified as being available for funding and the connection between this property and potential funding was ‘slim if it existed at all’.

The realistic prospect test

On the final and most major point, the High Court looked at whether the landlord had demonstrated that it had a realistic prospect of developing the site. This is the same test that is applied to the likelihood of obtaining planning permission and means that a ‘real chance’ must exist, not merely a ‘fanciful chance’. Sir Anthony Mann agreed that this test would also apply to the prospect of financing a development.

The landlord claimed that the judge in the original hearing had applied a different test, as he had referred several times to the landlord needing to prove that it ‘would be able to fund the development’.

The High Court agreed that this was a higher test, however the judge had applied the ‘real as opposed to fanciful’ test and when the original judgment was read as a whole, Sir Anthony Mann was satisfied that the judge had had the right test in mind. The landlord’s appeal was dismissed.

Lessons for landlords

The case highlights the need for landlords to be able to provide evidence that it has a realistic prospect of securing finance and planning permission to carry out a development and to ensure that this evidence is disclosed in accordance with the pre-trial protocols.

Contact our commercial litigation solicitors in Westminster, London

Joanne Smith is a senior solicitor in the Litigation and Dispute Resolution Department and deals with a broad range of commercial and residential property disputes.

If you would like to speak to Joanne, contact her by ringing 020 7873 1000, email her at law@williamsturges.co.uk or fill in our contact form below.

Share