Insights

Alternative Dispute Resolution

Mandatory Alternative Dispute Resolution Orders v The European Convention on Human Rights

Background to Alternative Dispute Resolution

The shift to Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) represents a significant transformation in how legal and civil disputes are managed, moving away from the formal and often rigid court system to more flexible and cooperative methods. This change has been motivated by several key factors:

Efficiency: Traditional court proceedings can be lengthy, often taking months or even years to resolve. ADR processes like mediation or arbitration are typically much faster, allowing parties to reach a resolution more quickly.

Cost-effectiveness: Litigation can be expensive, with costs including solicitor fees, court fees, and other expenses. ADR generally involves lower costs, as it reduces the need for extensive legal procedures and prolonged litigation.

Flexibility and control: The outcome of a claim at a final hearing or Trial is largely controlled by compliance with case management directions, legal procedures, the effectiveness of Counsel and the opinion of the Judge. ADR offers parties a degree of control over the process, allowing them to choose the method, the mediator or arbitrator, and even the rules that will govern the resolution. This flexibility often leads to more tailored and satisfactory outcomes.

Confidentiality: Court cases are typically public, which can be a concern for individuals or businesses looking to protect their privacy. ADR processes are usually confidential, which helps in preserving the privacy of the parties involved and maintaining the confidentiality of sensitive information.

Preservation of relationships: Traditional litigation can be adversarial, often damaging relationships between the parties involved. ADR, particularly mediation and negotiation, puts an emphasis on collaboration and communication, which can help preserve or even improve relationships by focusing on mutually beneficial solutions.

Wider applicability: ADR is used in various types of disputes. This versatility makes it an attractive option across different areas of law and conflict.

Global influence: The use of ADR has grown internationally, influenced by global trade and the need for quicker dispute resolution in cross-border transactions. Many international treaties and agreements now include provisions for ADR, further cementing its role in global conflict resolution.

Legal reforms: Many legal systems have reformed to encourage or even mandate ADR in certain types of cases. In England & Wales, parties are under a continuing obligation to consider ADR wheresoever possible, reflecting a broader institutional support for these methods.

What has changed?

In the case of Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416, the Court of Appeal determined whether mandatory ADR orders were contrary to Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights, thus finally laying to rest the uncertainty caused by the much-contested decision in the case of Halsey v Milton Keynes General NHS Trust [2004] 1 W.L.R. 2985.

The background to the proceedings in Churchill concerned a dispute arising in connection with Japanese knotweed. The claimant alleged that this evasive plant had encroached onto his property from the adjacent land owned by the defendant, which in turn had caused a reduction in its value and in the claimant’s enjoyment of it. The claimant issued proceedings, notwithstanding the defendant’s position that it would apply for a stay of the claim and costs if the claimant did so without first engaging with its Corporate Complaints Policy. The defendant’s subsequent application for a stay of the claim was dismissed on the basis that, according to Halsey, the court had no power to require unwilling parties to engage in a mediation process because to do so would amount to an impermissible fetter on the right to a fair trial.

It was held on appeal that:

(1) the statements made in Halsey regarding mandatory ADR were focussed on the issue of whether the court should impose costs sanctions upon a party that had refused to take part in ADR and were therefore not binding;

(2) courts had the power to mandate the use of ADR as long as the mandated process did not impair the essential essence of the right to fair trial and presented a proportionate means to promoting a fair settlement;

(3) the court ought to take various factors into account when exercising its discretion to mandate ADR, such as [the Bar Council guidelines] (i) the form of ADR being considered, (ii) whether the parties were legally advised or represented, (iii) whether ADR was likely to be effective or appropriate without such advice or representation, (iv) whether it was made clear to the parties that, if they did not settle, they were free to pursue their claim or defence, (v) the urgency of the case and the reasonableness of the delay caused by ADR, (vi) whether that delay would vitiate the claim or give rise to or exacerbate any limitation issues, (vii) the costs of ADR, (viii) whether there was any realistic prospect of the claim being resolved by ADR, (ix) whether there was a significant imbalance in the parties’ levels of resource, bargaining power or sophistication, (x) the reasons given by the party for not wishing to mediate, and (xi) the reasonableness and proportionality of the sanction; and

(4) the application for a stay of proceedings was refused.

What next

It is well-known that the court system in England & Wales is facing formidable pressures on its time, and the judgment in Churchill appears to follow the widespread recognition of the fact that its finite resources need to be deployed in a more appropriate manner.

The judgment in Churchill is also important for litigants and legal representatives, in that it has confirmed that the civil courts can direct parties to engage in “non-court-based dispute resolution” and has thereby unlocked the potential for further consideration as to how the courts apply this principle to different situations and different forms of ADR, without frustrating or denying a party’s access to justice.

Ultimately, although it was made clear by the Court of Appeal under Churchill that the Bar Council guidelines should not be treated as a checklist, the fact that the Court of Appeal has identified a range of potentially relevant factors in respect of how mandatory ADR can be carried out consistently with the right to a fair trial, suggests that the courts will be looking to litigants and their legal representatives to explore appropriate forms of ADR to promote consensual settlement.

Contact our commercial litigation solicitors in Westminster, London

Jai Sharda is a Partner in the Litigation and Dispute Resolution Department and is recognised as an expert in commercial dispute resolution and arbitration. If you would like to speak to Jai, contact him by ringing 020 7873 1000, email him at law@williamsturges.co.uk or fill in our contact form.

 

Share