Insights

Zymurgorium

A stark reminder to put all agreements into a binding contract

A recent Court of Appeal case has emphasised the importance of putting commercial agreements into writing. Partner and company and commercial solicitor Martin Donoghue takes a look at the details.

The facts

The case of Zymurgorium Ltd v Hammonds of Knutsford plc (2023) EWCA Civ 52 deals with whether implied contract terms or contract terms that are not in writing can be relied upon.

Zymurgorium Ltd (ZL) was a drinks manufacturer, while Hammonds of Knutsford plc (HK) was a wholesaler. At the start of the parties’ relationship, ZL was a small family business. It grew rapidly after some social media content promoting their drinks went viral.

HK discovered that ZL had been supplying one of its customers, JD Wetherspoon (JDW) directly. HK believed this to be in contravention of their agreement and ended the relationship. HK claimed that a contract had been created by express agreement during a meeting and that the parties had agreed during this meeting that ZL could not supply anyone except HK.

HK also claimed that five oral contracts in respect of five specific customers had been formed. It said that these related to the main contract and that because of this, exclusivity was implied into these oral contracts so that ZL could not supply JDW.

ZL brought a claim for payment of outstanding invoices. HK countersued for breach of contract, claiming that there was an unwritten agreement that ZL would exclusively supply HK.

The court initially denied that the main contract existed, but did find that there were five individual contracts relating to customers, one of which was JDW. By supplying JDW directly, ZL had breached this contract and this meant that the other four contracts were at an end.

The appeal

HK brought an appeal claiming that:

  • There was a contract between the parties
  • This agreement required their relationship to be exclusive

The Court of Appeal’s decision

The Court of Appeal upheld the high court decision saying that there was no agreement that ZL would only supply HK. Because exclusivity had never been referred to in correspondence following the meeting, it had not been agreed upon.

Conclusion

The case is a stark reminder that agreements, subsequent alterations and sub-contracts must all be clearly set out in writing. Relying on oral or implied agreements is never advisable and can easily end in misunderstandings and expensive legal arguments.

Clear contract clauses in respect of issues such as exclusivity are important and care should also be taken to ensure that agreements do not contradict each other.

Contact our company commercial solicitors in Westminster, London

Martin Donoghue is a partner in the Company and Commercial department. He represents businesses across a full range of sectors, ensuring robust contracts are in place that protect rights and interests and stand up to court scrutiny.

If you would like to speak to Martin or one of his team, call 020 7873 1000, email law@williamsturges.co.uk or fill in our contact form below.

Share