Insights

Green Lease

Court considers how ‘green’ changes to leases will be dealt with

With the government aiming to decarbonise all sectors of the UK economy and reach its target of net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, energy efficiency in property has become a hot topic.

The Minimum Energy Efficient Standard (MEES) regulations apply to domestic and commercial properties in England and Wales. Landlords are prohibited from granting a new lease unless a property has an Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) rating of E or higher, with A being the highest and most energy-efficient level. The minimum level is set to rise to C by the end of December 2028 where this is practical, cost-effective, and affordable.

Landlords who fail to meet the minimum standards can face sanctions for non-compliance. Tenants may also need to consider the MEES regulations when making alterations, fitting property out, and dealing with issues such as dilapidations and lease renewal.

In the case of Clipper Logistics plc v Scottish Equitable plc 2022, the court looked at what clauses would be allowed on lease renewal where costs relating to green compliance were a potential issue.

The facts

The landlord and tenant of an industrial unit were unable to agree on terms to be included in a new lease in respect of property alterations.

The landlord wanted the following clauses included:

  • The tenant to be prohibited from making alterations which would cause the property EPC to fall below an E rating – the ‘prohibition clause’
  • The tenant to indemnify the landlord for the cost of a new EPC if any alterations the tenant made invalidated or inversely affected the EPC – the ‘indemnity clause’
  • The tenant to be obliged to maintain the existing EPC rating, to return the premises to the landlord with the same EPC rating and to promptly carry out remedial works to restore the EPC rating, should it drop – the ‘reinstatement clause’

The landlord was concerned to avoid being in breach of MEES and facing penalties and the cost of remedial action.

The tenant held that the cost of complying with MEES was for the landlord to bear.

The decision

The court said that it was the landlord’s responsibility to ensure the property was compliant, although it noted that it could be in breach of the regulations through no fault of its own.

The court felt that the first two proposed clauses would unfairly and unreasonably require the tenant to take on duties which are by law the landlord’s duties to perform.

The existing lease prohibited the tenant from making alterations to the premises and there was therefore no reasonable requirement for the prohibition clause.

The indemnity clause would impose too substantial a burden on the tenant.

With regard to the reinstatement clause, the requirement for the tenant to return the property with the same EPC rating as it had when it initially took on the property was reasonable and should be implemented. It would protect the landlord from long-term inaction on the part of the tenant.

The rest of the proposed reinstatement clause was held to be too burdensome on the tenant, giving the landlord an unfair advantage.

The case is not legally binding and tenants are advised to seek legal advice before agreeing to onerous changes when taking on a new lease. Landlords are starting to consider green issues when negotiating renewals and it is crucial to fully consider whether these are fair or whether they place an unreasonable burden on the tenant.

Contact our commercial or residential property solicitors in Westminster, London

Uzma Hussan specialises in all aspects of residential property transactions including residential sales and purchases, newbuilds, refinancing, lease extensions and transfers of equity.

If you would like to speak to one of our expert commercial or residential property solicitors, call 020 7873 1000, email law@williamsturges.co.uk or fill in our contact form below.

Share